Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Metal-Free Jewelry

Last updated on July 19, 2022

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Metal-Free Jewelry

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

Jstyle Assorted Shapes Rhinestone Stud Plastic Post Earrings, 12-Pairs

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval


Assorted Shapes Rhinestone Stud Plastic Post Earrings, 12-Pairs

You’ll get 12 pairs of earrings in various shapes, including hearts, stars, triangles, squares, round and flowers. Each earring features a plastic post made from quality acrylic that’s both hypoallergenic and durable. The jewels are white rhinestones to provide plenty of sparkle.

Overall Take

Great GiftThe included black pouch makes this set perfect for gifting.

 Runner Up

CrazyPiercing Acrylic Belly Barbells Metal-Free Jewelry, 100-Piece


Acrylic Belly Barbells Metal-Free Jewelry, 100-Piece

This set comes with lots of options for belly button rings and barbells. Each one is completely unique. The jewelry is made from high-quality acrylic material.

Overall Take

Lots of OptionsThis set comes with 100 metal-free belly button rings and barbells.

 We Also Like

QWALIT Plastic Stud Earrings Metal-Free Jewelry, 8-Piece


Plastic Stud Earrings Metal-Free Jewelry, 8-Piece

These studs are highly versatile and can be used as lip rings or tragus earrings. They feature a shiny cubic zirconia stone. The studs are available in different sizes.

Overall Take

Versatile ChoiceThese studs can be used as lip rings or earrings.

 Strong Contender

Pretty Smart Succulent Design Hypoallergenic Plastic Post Earrings

Pretty Smart

Succulent Design Hypoallergenic Plastic Post Earrings

Available in a variety of colors, this pair of floral earrings is great to give as a gift or buy for yourself. The design is free from metals and BPA for a safe alternative to traditional metal earrings. The earrings arrive in a gift box with extra rubber backs included.

Overall Take

Classy and ElegantA simple but colorful floral design makes this pair of earrings an elegant option for those who can’t wear metals.

Buying Guide

While jewelry made from metals such as gold, silver and platinum are quite common, they just don’t work for some people. If you have a skin sensitivity or allergy to metals, then swollen fingers and earlobes aren’t worth the benefits of wearing something made of metal. Other people find that metallic jewelry turns green or rusts, which can be another reason to go in a different direction.

When it comes to metal-free jewelry, there are so many options to choose from. Wooden jewelry has a stunning natural look and is also eco-friendly. This type of jewelry is eye-catching with intricate carvings and embellishments. Keep in mind that wooden jewelry is fairly delicate, and it cannot be resized like metal jewelry.

For many people, plastic jewelry is a great choice that is cost effective and durable. You can even find plastic versions of gems, such as pearls and diamonds. Use plastic for jewelry that goes on top of the skin, such as necklaces and rings. For jewelry that goes inside piercings, such as earrings and nose rings, opt for bioplastic materials which are designed to reduce infections.

A unique option that you may not have considered before is jewelry made from shells. This naturally occurring material has been used to make jewelry for thousands of years – and still looks trendy to this day. You can find jewelry made from different types of shells, such as puka, cowrie, oyster, abalone and more. Just be sure to purchase shell jewelry from a source that considers the environment and doesn’t harm marine life in the process.

What to Look For

  • Ceramic isn’t just for dishes. Did you know you can get non-metal jewelry made from ceramic? It’s a durable and hypoallergenic option for rings, necklaces, bracelets and much more.
  • If durability and flexibility are of high importance, then give rubber jewelry a try. This jewelry is made from synthetic rubber mixed with plastic polymers. It’s hypoallergenic, comfortable and flexible. Many people choose rubber rings because they are so durable and easy to remove. Plus, you can get rubber jewelry in almost any color.
  • Leather jewelry is a good alternative to metal, especially for necklaces and bracelets. While it is not vegan, this material works for many people who prefer jewelry made from natural materials.
  • Acrylic is another excellent metal-free jewelry option because it is safe and doesn’t react with the skin. It’s especially useful for people who have severe metal allergies. You can find acrylic earrings, rings, nose rings and more.
  • Keep your entire outfit in mind when deciding on which metal-free jewelry to wear as certain materials look better with certain looks. For example, if you’re going for a bohemian vibe, opt for wooden bracelets. Glass earrings are elegant and work well with formal dresses. Want something that looks edgy? Try a leather necklace.
  • Just like with other fashion accessories, don’t be afraid to mix and match. You don’t just have to wear all wooden jewelry or all plastic jewelry, for example. Pair plastic bangles with wooden earrings or a leather cuff with a glass ring.

More to Explore

Glass is a stunning non-metal jewelry option. Fused glass has different colors that are melted and combined for a unique look that cannot be replicated. Another type is dichroic glass which refracts different colors based on how the light hits it. If you like the look of genuine stones but can’t stomach the price tag, glass beads are a great option. They are typically held together with elastic string to make necklaces and earrings. Murano glass is hand-crafted by artisans, and as a result is a pricy option. If you’re looking for something natural, try sea glass, which is made by glass that has been smoothed by the waves in the sea.

From our partners