Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Mechanics Tool Set

Last updated on July 7, 2020

We looked at the top 13 Mechanics Tool Sets and dug through the reviews from 25 of the most popular review sites including Circuits at Home, A Top Daily, SafeRoad, Put Product Reviews, Wire Vibes, Garage Tool Advisor and more. The result is a ranking of the best Mechanics Tool Sets.

Best Mechanics Tool Set

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Mechanics Tool Sets

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  The Best Overall

DEWALT DWMT72165 Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

DEWALT

Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

Overall Take

Great Starter SetIf you're looking for a comprehensive kit to get started on your repairs, this 204-piece kit is a great choice.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus The Truth About Cars. Along with user reviews from Amazon, Home Depot and Walmart.
Pros
" Good name, great reviews"

GEARWRENCH 6-Point 120XP Standard & Deep Mechanics Tool Set, 56-Piece

GEARWRENCH

6-Point Mechanics Tool Set, 56-Piece

Overall Take

Double-Stacked PawlsWith this set, you get two double-stacked 60 tooth pawls that provide extra power with each turn.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus . Along with user reviews from Amazon and Home Depot.
  The Best Value

AmazonBasics Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

AmazonBasics

Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

Overall Take

Chrome Vanadium Forged BodyThe ratchets in this set have a Chrome Vanadium forged body to provide enhanced strength and durability.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus Garage Tool Advisor, Circuits at Home, The Truth About Cars. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" For those who are looking for a good budget mechanic’s set, this 145-piece set Amazon-branded set is good option. AmazonBasics is more known for their popular low-cost home electronic accessories and household items but they’ve now branched out to other..."
Cons
"You'll have to explain the brand name to yer buddies"

CRAFTSMAN CMMT12024 SAE Metric Mechanics Tool Set, 135-Piece

CRAFTSMAN

Mechanics Tool Set, 135-Piece

Overall Take

Markings for IdentificationEasily find the tool you need with the large, easy-to-read markings that help you quickly find the socket you need.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus . Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
20

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the mechanics tool sets available to purchase.
13

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

25

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: Circuits at Home, A Top Daily, SafeRoad, Put Product Reviews, Wire Vibes.

22,629

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon, Walmart, Home Depot and 5 others.

Our experts reviewed the top 13 Mechanics Tool Sets and also dug through the reviews from 25 of the most popular review sites including Circuits at Home, A Top Daily, SafeRoad, Put Product Reviews, Wire Vibes, Garage Tool Advisor and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Mechanics Tool Sets.

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

DEWALT DWMT72165 Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

Our Expert Score
10.0
1 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.3
2,110 user reviews
Our Take

This tool set includes 204 pieces, including sockets, ratchets and extension bars. You'll have everything you need for your home toolkit. The blow-molded case is built to protect the pieces inside, with a handle that makes it easy to carry from one place to the next. It's a great deal when you compare it to what you'd pay buying each of the items inside separately.

What other experts liked
Good name, great reviews
- The Truth About Cars
What other experts didn't like
Make sure you get exactly what you ordered
- The Truth About Cars

The Best Bang For Your Buck

AmazonBasics Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

Our Expert Score
0.0
3 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.2
1,571 user reviews
Our Take

You'll get a full set of socket tools with this 145-piece set in a sturdy carrying case. You'll get sockets in a variety of sizes, as well as screwdriver bits, hex keys and wrenches, among other items. The socket bodies are made from forged chrome-vanadium steel and coated with a polished chrome finish, giving it a high-quality look while also providing years of use.

What other experts liked
For those who are looking for a good budget mechanic’s set, this 145-piece set Amazon-branded set is good option. AmazonBasics is more known for their popular low-cost home electronic accessories and household items but they’ve now branched out to other areas which will almost certainly be a hit as well....
- Garage Tool Advisor
The AmazonBasics Mechanics Tool Kit takes the DEKOPRO approach to value and takes it up a notch. As with all other products in the AmazonBasics line, it’s a no-frills approach that Amazon hopes will provide you with everything you need to get started. It’s worth pointing out that although we’re...
- Circuits at Home
Positive reviews, includes deep and shallow sockets of many sizes
- The Truth About Cars
What other experts didn't like
You'll have to explain the brand name to yer buddies
- The Truth About Cars

Overall Product Rankings

DEWALT DWMT72165 Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

1. DEWALT DWMT72165 Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

Overall Score: 9.8
Reviews Included: 5

AmazonBasics Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

3. AmazonBasics Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

Overall Score: 9.4
Reviews Included: 4

DEWALT DWMT75049 Mechanics Tool Set, 192-Piece

5. DEWALT DWMT75049 Mechanics Tool Set, 192-Piece

Overall Score: 9.2
Reviews Included: 5

DEWALT DWMT73802 Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 142-Piece

7. DEWALT DWMT73802 Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 142-Piece

Overall Score: 9.2
Reviews Included: 4

Stanley STMT71654 Mechanics Tool Set, 201-Piece

8. Stanley STMT71654 Mechanics Tool Set, 201-Piece

Overall Score: 9.2
Reviews Included: 5

Hi-Spec Auto Mechanics Tool Set, 67-Piece

10. Hi-Spec Auto Mechanics Tool Set, 67-Piece

Overall Score: 8.6
Reviews Included: 5

Wilnerkot Household Mechanics Tool Set, 205-Piece

11. Wilnerkot Household Mechanics Tool Set, 205-Piece

Overall Score: 8.4
Reviews Included: 1

DEKOPRO Auto Repair Mechanics Tool Set, 192-Piece

12. DEKOPRO Auto Repair Mechanics Tool Set, 192-Piece

Overall Score: 8.3
Reviews Included: 5

Our Mechanics Tool Set Findings

DEWALT DWMT72165 Mechanics Tool Set, 204-Piece

What We Liked: This tool set includes 204 pieces, including sockets, ratchets and extension bars. You’ll have everything you need for your home toolkit. The blow-molded case is built to protect the pieces inside, with a handle that makes it easy to carry from one place to the next. It’s a great deal when you compare it to what you’d pay buying each of the items inside separately.

GEARWRENCH 6-Point 120XP Standard & Deep Mechanics Tool Set, 56-Piece

What We Liked: This wrench set includes 56 pieces, including standard and deep sockets. The 120XP ratchets feature a 3-degree swing arc to ensure you can tighten even in the smallest area. The pawls are double stacked, which gives you more strength as you’re turning.

AmazonBasics Socket Mechanics Tool Set, 145-Piece

What We Liked: You’ll get a full set of socket tools with this 145-piece set in a sturdy carrying case. You’ll get sockets in a variety of sizes, as well as screwdriver bits, hex keys and wrenches, among other items. The socket bodies are made from forged chrome-vanadium steel and coated with a polished chrome finish, giving it a high-quality look while also providing years of use.

CRAFTSMAN CMMT12024 SAE Metric Mechanics Tool Set, 135-Piece

What We Liked: This 135-piece set comes in a bright red case to help you easily identify it as yours. It comes with 72 ratchets in three different drive sizes to provide maximum control. The chrome finish helps prevent corrosion, ensuring you’ll get years of durable use.

WORKPRO W009044A 3-Drawer Heavy Duty Mechanics Metal Box Set

What We Liked: The ratchet handles in this kit come with a thumb-operated switch that makes it easy to release the socket. The chrome vanadium forged body provides the durability and strength you need. In addition to ratchets and sockets, you’ll also get measuring tape, a boxcutter, pliers and zip ties.

Our Mechanics Tool Set Buying Guide

Automotive repairs require special tools, whether you’re working on a car, truck, motorcycle or a vehicle like a riding lawnmower. You may already have some basic tools, but if you’re equipping your garage to tackle some serious repairs on a regular basis, it’s worth an investment in a specialized mechanic’s toolset.

If you have a toolkit that you use for basic household tasks, you have a good start on a mechanic’s toolset. A good pair of pliers and a full set of screwdrivers will come into play far more often than you expect. You may also already have a good pair of latex gloves, which are much more useful in protecting your hands than mechanic’s work gloves, which can be too thick for many tasks.

But those basics are only the start. One item that’s essential to any mechanic is a toolset specifically designed for working on vehicles. It will include sockets, extensions and a ratchet, at minimum. You’ll need varying sizes of sockets and ratchets, so you can save money and time by simply buying a kit with a wide range of options from the outset.

You should also invest in a torque wrench for tightening nuts, but when it’s time to remove a nut or bolt, you’ll turn to your ratchet toolkit, either using one of your ratchets or a breaker bar. When you choose a torque wrench, carefully coordinate it with the drive size of your socket set.

Chances are, you’ll need to get underneath your car from time to time. For that, a car ramp will be required. You can instead choose a jack, but ramps tend to be safer. Your ramp will come in handy when it’s time to change the oil in your vehicle, which is a task you’ll perform fairly often. For oil changes, you’ll also need an oil drain pan to keep messes to a minimum, as well as an oil funnel for replacing the oil you’ve drained.

You may think a jumper box is something you’ll only need on the rare occasion your battery dies. But when you start working on cars, you’ll be surprised how often you accidentally drain the battery, and having a jumper box in your garage will help you get your car started again afterward.

Once you’ve purchased these basics, you can add to your tools as needed. Make sure you have plenty of extra storage space for all the items you’ll buy as you advance in your DIY mechanic work.

DWYM Fun Fact

By now, you’ve probably heard varying advice on how often you should change your car’s oil. That sticker the mechanic places on your windshield after each visit likely recommends every three months or 3,000 miles, whichever comes first. In recent years, though, experts have changed their tune on how often you need to take your car in. Your vehicle’s manual will give an exact guideline, but Scientific American says you can probably push it to 5,000 to 7,500 miles. If you drive less frequently, though, you’ll need to pay closer attention to the timeline rather than what your odometer says. Six months is the timeline many experts recommend, but by checking your oil monthly, you can get a better gauge of when it’s time. The more opaque your oil is, the more likely it’s time for a change. If your oil is milky, it could be a sign you’re leaking coolant.

The Mechanics Tool Set Tips and Advice

  • By buying your repair tools in a kit, you often save significant money over buying each item separately. Additionally, you’ll get a case that helps you keep everything neatly stored in one place.
  • Toolsets for mechanics come in a variety of sizes, from smaller sets with just over 50 pieces to those that have hundreds of pieces. You’ll find a combination of sockets and multiple ratchets, but often there are other items, as well, including extension bars. The larger and more comprehensive the toolset, the less likely you’ll have to head back to the store in the middle of your work.
  • Some toolsets come with handy extras like measuring tape and pliers. Even if you already have these items in your house, it can be nice to have an extra set for your garage or work shed.
  • Pay particular attention to the case the tools are stored in. Many have thick, durable cases that keep your tools safely stored when not in use. But make sure the set has a compartment for each ratchet and socket to avoid items getting scratched up from rubbing against each other.
  • Many ratchets feature a finish designed to ensure they last through many uses without rusting or corroding.
  • Ratchets come in varying drive sizes, each used for different tasks. Some of the most common sizes are 1/4-inch drive, 1/2-inch drive and 3/8-inch drive. You’ll find that you change from one to another throughout the course of your work.
  • For general use, you’ll likely need a gearless ratchet, which uses a rolling bearing, reducing the effort you have to put into your work. There are also jointed and flex-head ratchets, which require a little more manual labor but can help you get into those tight areas.
  • You’ll also find ratchets vary in tooth count. The higher the tooth count, the easier you’ll find the handle is to move around while you’re working.
  • There is a wide range of socket types, each with their own unique uses. If you’re new to working on cars, you may not realize the full scope of what you’ll need. Having a set with a variety of sizes will be a big help in those early months.
  • Ratchets vary in operation. Some are easier to twist and turn than others, while some feature conveniences like release valves that make it easy to eject the socket. These small things will add up if you’re using the ratchet regularly.
  • You’ll find your work will call for sockets of varying sizes and depths. Don’t underestimate the value of a kit that contains a wide range of socket sizes. You’ll likely find you need many of them over the course of your work.
  • For some, the brand is important. Although there are many trusted brands in toolsets, you can save money and get the same value from a lesser-known name. Still, if you want to impress your buddies, you may want to either go with a tried-and-true brand or look for a toolkit that doesn’t blast its name across the front.

About The Author

Avatar
Stephanie Faris 

Stephanie Faris is a novelist and business writer whose work has appeared on numerous blogs. She worked for the State of Tennessee for 19 years, the latter six of which were spent as a supervisor. She has written content for entrepreneurs and marketing firms since 2011. In addition to her online content, she is also the author of eight novels for Simon & Schuster, including the Piper Morgan chapter book series.