Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Mascara - 2022

Last updated on July 6, 2022

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top

Show Contents
Our Take
  Top Pick

Essence Lash Princess Cruelty & Gluten-Free Mascara

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Essence

Lash Princess Cruelty & Gluten-Free Mascara

Overall Take

Dramatic LookThis mascara gives you lots of volume and length.

  Runner Up

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Clump-Resistant Waterproof Mascara

L’Oreal Paris

Voluminous Clump-Resistant Waterproof Mascara

Overall Take

Fuller LashesThis mascara offers four times the volume.

  We Also Like

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Vegan Paraben-Free Mascara

COVERGIRL

Lash Blast Clean Vegan Paraben-Free Mascara

Overall Take

Vegan FormulaThis mascara is made with argan and marula oils.

  Strong Contender

Maybelline Lash Sensational 10-Layer Fanning Brush Mascara

Maybelline

Lash Sensational 10-Layer Fanning Brush Mascara

Overall Take

Full EffectThis mascara offers a sensational look.

Guide written by Anam Ahmed
Last updated on July 6, 2022

For most makeup lovers, mascara is an essential item they cannot live without. It not only lifts and darkens our eyelashes, but helps to brighten our eyes and make them stand out. If you’re searching for the perfect mascara but aren’t sure what to consider, then you’re in the right place.

One of the most annoying things about low-quality mascara is that it comes on thick and clumpy. This looks unappealing and can also be difficult to remove. A good mascara should stretch and lengthen the lashes with a high-definition formula. Opt for a mascara that contains emollient moisturizer from olives which helps to reduce clumping while offering a smooth glide.

Go for a mascara that sets and dries quickly. If it takes too long, you will have difficult applying multiple coats and it may get smudged when you blink. Mascara that dries quickly helps you get ready faster – and looks more professional as well. In addition, long lasting products are key. Look for mascara that has high-quality ingredients which don’t damage the lashes – but hold color and length all day long.

An important factor you shouldn’t forget about is the brush. The way the brush is shaped will no doubt affect the way your lashes look, regardless of the mascara formula. For instance, if the brush is big and bushy, so too will your lashes be. If the brush is thin and spiky, you lashes will have a separated look. Consider the type of eyelash look you want and get a brush the matches.

The Best

1
  Top Pick

Essence Lash Princess Cruelty & Gluten-Free Mascara

This mascara offers dramatic volume and length. It lasts all day without fading or flaking. The mascara helps to define and separate each lash for a bold look.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Essence
Model
2
  Runner Up

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Clump-Resistant Waterproof Mascara

This bold mascara makes your lashes look four times fuller. It separates every lash and doesn’t clump. The mascara is waterproof and won’t streak.

Features


Specifications

Brand
L’Oreal Paris
Model
3
  We Also Like

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Vegan Paraben-Free Mascara

This mascara is vegan and made with argan and marula oils. It is cruelty free and never tested on animals. The mascara provides ten times the volume as compared bare lashes.

Features


Specifications

Brand
COVERGIRL
Model
4
  Strong Contender

Maybelline Lash Sensational 10-Layer Fanning Brush Mascara

This mascara offers a full effect with the fanning brush. It defines your eyes whether you like a dramatic or natural look. The mascara can be removed with Micellar Water.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Maybelline
Model
5
  Also Great

Too Faced Better Than Sex Acacia Senegal Extract Mascara

This mascara offers voluptuous volume thanks to the hourglass-shaped brush. It curls the lashes into place. The mascara also thickens and lengthens lashes.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Too Faced
Model

Our Buying Guide

For most makeup lovers, mascara is an essential item they cannot live without. It not only lifts and darkens our eyelashes, but helps to brighten our eyes and make them stand out. If you’re searching for the perfect mascara but aren’t sure what to consider, then you’re in the right place.

One of the most annoying things about low-quality mascara is that it comes on thick and clumpy. This looks unappealing and can also be difficult to remove. A good mascara should stretch and lengthen the lashes with a high-definition formula. Opt for a mascara that contains emollient moisturizer from olives which helps to reduce clumping while offering a smooth glide.

Go for a mascara that sets and dries quickly. If it takes too long, you will have difficult applying multiple coats and it may get smudged when you blink. Mascara that dries quickly helps you get ready faster – and looks more professional as well. In addition, long lasting products are key. Look for mascara that has high-quality ingredients which don’t damage the lashes – but hold color and length all day long.

An important factor you shouldn’t forget about is the brush. The way the brush is shaped will no doubt affect the way your lashes look, regardless of the mascara formula. For instance, if the brush is big and bushy, so too will your lashes be. If the brush is thin and spiky, you lashes will have a separated look. Consider the type of eyelash look you want and get a brush the matches.

DWYM Fun Fact

Some types of mascara can be difficult to remove. Remember to work in the direction your lashes grow with a cotton pad and makeup remover. If you wipe against the direction of the growth, you can damage your lashes or end up pulling them out. Your eyes and eyelashes are delicate, so be gentle when removing the makeup. Don’t rub, pull or scrub. Just gently wipe your lashes with the cotton pad. Make sure your eyes are closed when you’re removing the mascara, so nothing gets into your eyes and harms them.

The Tips and Advice

  • Waterproof mascara was all the rage for a time, but there are other options, such as water-resistant mascara. Waterproof mascara can sometimes leave a ring around your eyes – not to mention it is very difficult to fully remove. Water-resistant mascara prevents streaks and running but uses water-soluble ingredients so it’s easier to take off.
  • Did you know there are different types of mascara formulas for different types of looks and lashes? For example, if you want evenly spaced lashes, then you need a light formula. If your lashes are long and straight, you can get a curling mascara which shapes your lashes upward. If you have really short lashes, you can get a lengthening mascara formula. For those who have really sensitive skin and eyes, it’s best to use a wax-based mascara which doesn’t crumble.
  • Is all mascara black? For the most part, the answer is yes. However, if you have light blond hair, you may want to consider a brown-black mascara formula, which will work better with your hair and coloring. Some specialty mascaras are available in colors such as blue, purple and green.
  • When you come home late at night from a long day, you may be tempted to forego removing your makeup before you go to bed. While it may be more convenient, sleeping with mascara (and any other makeup) can be damaging for your skin and eyes on a long-term basis. Always take the extra few minutes to use makeup remover and wash your face and then moisturize your skin before getting into bed.

About The Author

Anam Ahmed 

Anam Ahmed is a professional copywriter and essayist based in Toronto. She has been writing on technology, travel, parenting, and business for over 10 years, and works with a number of high-profile organizations. As a skincare-obsessed product junkie, she values finding the best beauty products that make people shine. Anam earned a master's degree from the University of Toronto and a bachelor's degree from Queen's University.