Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Eye Shadow Pencil

Last updated on July 7, 2022

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Eyeshadow Pencils

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Liner & Eyeshadow Pencil

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval


Jumbo Liner & Eyeshadow Pencil

This versatile, highly blendable eye shadow pencil works as a smooth, creamy shadow, eyeliner or highlighter. It comes in many colors that range from subtle to bold, matte to sparkly. It's also made by a PETA-certified cruelty-free cosmetic brand.

Overall Take

It's 3-in-1You can look gorgeous and feel 100% good about using this cruelty-free eye shadow!

 Runner Up

LUXAZA Buildable Waterproof Eyeshadow Pencils, 6-Piece


Buildable Waterproof Eyeshadow Pencils, 6-Piece

This product offers the utmost convenience. You get six complementary eye shadow pencils in one package. Each hue will help accent, shape and sculpt your eyes however you like.

Overall Take

Half a Dozen ColorsUse all six shades in a variety of different blended combinations.

 We Also Like

Glo Skin Beauty Built-In Sharpener 12 Hour Eyeshadow Pencil

Glo Skin Beauty

Built-In Sharpener 12 Hour Eyeshadow Pencil

Glo Skin's cream eye shadow stick comes in 12 colors and lasts up to 12 hours. The richly pigmented shades contain nourishing minerals, glide easily onto the skin and even come with a built-in sharpener.

Overall Take

Smooth ApplicationYou'll want to make this creamy eye shadow part of your regular daily makeup routine.

 Strong Contender

Julep Vitamin C & E Waterproof Eyeshadow Pencil


Vitamin C & E Waterproof Eyeshadow Pencil

This waterproof, highly pigmented, blendable crème-to-powder eye shadow pencil is offered in 30 matte, metallic and shimmer finishes. It contains nourishing, hydrating ingredients like vitamins C and E and candelilla wax.

Overall Take

Made With Natural IngredientsUse this pencil to highlight your eyes while improving your skin texture at the same time.

Buying Guide

Eye shadow pencils (also called eye shadow sticks) are a relatively recent entry into the world of makeup, and they are lauded for their ease of application and versatility. Powder eye shadows can be tricky to put on and don’t always last as long or blend as well as cream types.

Powdered eye shadows can be messy to apply, while the newer sticks and pencils contain formulas that glide smoothly like cream and dry into powders. Since they are in stick form, you can be more accurate with their application.

Besides the noticeable difference in consistency, eye shadow sticks are easier to layer than other eye makeup products. Plus, they’re versatile: You can use them for an eye shadow base, eyeliner or even highlighter. Many are sold individually, while others are sold in sets of two or more complementary colors. They also contain waxes and other ingredients that make them last longer.

A great thing about these products is that they aren’t as messy to store and carry around as powder and cream eye shadows. You can remove the cover, twist up the stick, apply, twist it down and close it shut. You can find eye shadow sticks with built-in sharpeners or ones that twist up, which you’ll need to sharpen. You should always sharpen them over a trash can to easily collect and dispose of the shavings.

This eye makeup is sold in every possible color you can imagine (and more), and in matte, metallic and shimmery finishes. Some tips are on the narrower side, while others are wider; you can also find waterproof and water-resistant versions. Most blend quite easily, so you can enjoy experimenting with different looks. Try another color or color combination if you don’t like how one looks.

What to Look For

  • If dry skin is an issue, look for eye shadow pencils that contain hydrating and nourishing ingredients like vitamins and jojoba oil.
  • Many of these products also come with one or more smudge tips to help you blend in the color.
  • You can also use eye shadow sticks for your eyebrows!
  • Extra-wide eye shadow sticks are best for eye shadow bases, and you can also use them as contour sticks.
  • Matte neutral eye shadow sticks create more natural-looking appearances.
  • Apply the eye shadow stick lightly for a sheer look, and build it up when you want to go bolder.
  • If you experience redness, swelling, burning, itching or tingling after using a makeup product, you may be allergic to it. Discontinue use immediately and clean the area; contact your doctor if the reaction is severe.

More to Explore

Cosmetics have existed since ancient times in places like Rome and Egypt. The companies that manufacture and sell many of these products have been around for longer than you might think, too.

Pond’s cold cream isn’t generally considered makeup, but the original owners of this cosmetics company established it in 1846. Kiehl’s came a few years later, in 1851. Shiseido manufactures makeup and started as a Tokyo pharmacy in 1872; its Eudermine toner is still sold to this day.

From our partners