The Best Colorful Eyeliner
We looked at the top 10 Colorful Eyeliners and dug through the reviews from 12 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best Colorful Eyeliners.
Our Review Process
Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.
Many people love eyeliner for its remarkable ability to enhance their eyes and make them pop. It can make a look go from day to night; it can be natural or vivid; subtle or stunning. No matter how you choose to wear it, finding the right product for you can be a bit of a challenge at times.
You probably know that eyeliner comes in various colors; commonly, people gravitate toward black, brown, navy blue, green and purple. However, did you know that more colorful eyeliners are on the market? The use of vibrant hues for eye makeup has been popular lately, with many people of all ages and style preferences opting for this fun and unique look.
If you’re thinking about trying out colorful eyeliner, keep a few things in mind. First, you should consider the type of look you’re going for. Do you want something subtle or more dramatic? The type of eyeliner you choose will also depend on the occasion. For example, you might want a more subdued look during the day and then amp it up for a night out.
There are two main types of eyeliner: pencil and liquid. Pencil eyeliner is easier to apply and creates a more natural style. Liquid eyeliner, on the other hand, is perfect for creating a bold and dramatic look. This typically comes in an applicator that looks a bit like a felt-tipped pen.
Some eyeliner types straddle the line between pencil and liquid, with creamy pencil-style choices. In some cases, colorful eyeliners may be available in multiple types from the same company. If you find a hue you love, you could luck out with the type of formula you prefer, too.
Our Picks For The Top Colorful Eyeliners
- 1. Rechoo Matte Rainbow Liquid Colorful Eyeliner, 12 Count
- 2. Julep Smoky Plum Sharpenable Longwear Colorful Eyeliner
- 3. COOSA Waterproof Creme Gel Colorful Eyeliner, 20 Count
- 4. BestLand Pigmented Waterproof Colorful Gel Eyeliner, 12 Count
- 5. LemonSac Metallic & Glitter Colorful Eyeliner, 15 Count
- 6. CHARMCODE Matte Liquid Colorful Eyeliner, 14 Count
- 7. Ownest Matte Liquid Neon Colorful Eyeliner, 12 Count
- 8. CaliGlam Waterproof Matte Liquid Colorful Eyeliner, 16 Count
- 9. Linble Hypoallergenic Matte Colorful Eyeliner, 12 Count
- 10. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Colorful Eyeliner
Rechoo has created 12 shades of the rainbow in these perfect liquid eyeliner pens. They come in two styles: one is a pen, and the other is a pot with a wand. This set offers you an amazing sea of choices so you'll never feel your look is lacking.
Easy to UseThis eyeliner is a matte formula, meaning it will not dry shiny. This is nice touch, as it won't reflect the sun in an unpleasant manner.
This beautiful matte eyeliner comes in 20 colors. It is formulated as a sharpenable pencil that glides on like a gel. Julep's long-lasting cosmetics are formulated with extra-finely milled pigments, creating an intense color payoff that onlookers won't miss.
Lasts All DayThanks to its unique wax blend, this gel glides on smoothly and comfortably.
Coosa's waterproof eyeliner pencil set comes with an astonishing 20 colored eyeliner pencils. This set has it all, ranging from matte to shiny. It even provides 12 hours of waterproof, long-lasting wear in any weather.
Holds Up to SweatTo remove this eyeliner, gently wipe off with an eye makeup remover.
There's nothing worse than smudging your perfectly applied gel eyeliner. But with BestLand's eyeliner, worry no more. This 12-piece set dries quickly, helping you get out the door faster.
A Rainbow of OptionsThis eyeliner set comes in three different options for color combos, so it's wonderful if you like to experiment with your look.
Why we recommend these colorful eyeliners?
Products Considered
Products Analyzed
Expert Reviews Included
User Opinions Analyzed
Our experts reviewed the top 10 Colorful Eyeliners and also dug through the reviews from 12 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Colorful Eyeliners.
DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.
The Best Overall
Rechoo Matte Rainbow Liquid Colorful Eyeliner, 12 Count
Our Take
Rechoo has created 12 shades of the rainbow in these perfect liquid eyeliner pens. They come in two styles: one is a pen, and the other is a pot with a wand. This set offers you an amazing sea of choices so you'll never feel your look is lacking.
What other experts liked
What other experts didn't like
The Best Bang For Your Buck
COOSA Waterproof Creme Gel Colorful Eyeliner, 20 Count
Our Take
Coosa's waterproof eyeliner pencil set comes with an astonishing 20 colored eyeliner pencils. This set has it all, ranging from matte to shiny. It even provides 12 hours of waterproof, long-lasting wear in any weather.
What other experts liked
What other experts didn't like
What to Look For
- Choose the right color for your eyes. If you have blue eyes, opt for purple or green eyeliner. For brown eyes, try a gold or bronze shade. If you have hazel eyes, go for an orange or pink eyeliner.
- Experiment with different types of eyeliner. You can create different looks using different types of eyeliner.
- Remove waterproof makeup with an oil-based cleanser. Massage the cleanser into your skin and rinse it with warm water.
- When applying liquid eyeliner, start from the middle of your lash line and work your way out. This method will help you create a more even and symmetrical look.
Colorful Eyeliner Rankings
4. BestLand Pigmented Waterproof Colorful Gel Eyeliner, 12 Count
8. CaliGlam Waterproof Matte Liquid Colorful Eyeliner, 16 Count
More to Explore
While you may think eyeliner is a modern invention, its origins can actually be traced back to early civilization.
The first recorded use of eyeliner was in ancient Egypt. Egyptians used it to protect their eyes from the harsh desert sun. (We still do this today for some sports, like the eye black sticks used by football players.)
For Ancient Egyptian women, this cosmetic product doubled as a way to enhance their look; lined eyes were thought to be more attractive. In ancient Greece, eyeliner was worn by both men and women.
During the Roman Empire, people used eyeliner to signify social status. Wealthy women would wear thick black eyeliner, while poorer women would wear thinner lines of eyeliner. In the Middle Ages, eyeliner fell out of fashion and wasn’t seen again until the early 1900s. Today, eyeliner is worn by women worldwide and is available in various colors and styles.
Latest Reviews
